eBay forced free 30-day returns across most Parts & Accessories categories. If you sell used parts out of a salvage yard, your reaction was probably a single question: does this apply to me?
It does not - so long as the listing genuinely says used. eBay's own Seller Center page states the condition requirement as "the item is new or new other". Used items are outside it.
That is the answer most yards need and most articles hedge on. The part worth your attention is what it does not settle.
Which listings ARE caught?
| Condition you listed | Covered? | Why it matters |
|---|---|---|
| Used | No | Outside the rule entirely |
| New | Yes | New-old-stock on a shelf is still new |
| New other | Yes | Open box, surplus, unfitted |
| Remanufactured | Depends on the value you chose | Worth deciding deliberately |
A yard inventory is not uniformly used. You have new-old-stock that was manufactured years ago and never fitted. Surplus that arrived in packaging. Remanufactured units. Every one of those gets a condition value at listing time, and that value is what a rule keyed on "new" reads.
The five exclusions a yard should know
Some categories are outside the rule regardless of condition, and they are conspicuously the heavy, high-value end of a salvage yard:
- Wheels, tires, tire and wheel packages, and other wheel and tire parts
- Automatic and manual transmissions
- Complete engines
- Airbags
- Anything shipped freight rather than parcel
The reason is obvious once you have paid to freight a transmission back. It also means that for a yard whose revenue concentrates in drivetrain, the rule touches a smaller share of the business than the headlines suggest.
What the rule does where it does apply
- Thirty days, remorse included. Not just damaged or not-as-described - the buyer can change their mind.
- Fixed-price listings only, on items over $10, shipped to US buyers from US sellers.
- eBay covers 50% of the return label on a remorse return. If the buyer reports it arrived damaged or did not match the description, you pay the full label.
- You cannot opt out. Participation is required in the applicable categories, and continuing to list in them without free returns stops being an option.
One detail is worth more than the rest, and it points back at fitment: for a part that does not fit under the Guaranteed Fit programme, eBay pays the full return label rather than half.
Which is a real incentive to get the compatibility table right, and a real cost when it is wrong - that table is also what decides whether you are found at all.
What still applies to your used parts anyway
Being outside the free-returns rule does not mean being outside the returns system. A buyer can still open a case. A part can still come back. And the consequence that actually bites is unchanged.
6
Defects for an entire year, at 300 sales a year. Under 400 transactions in three months means you are measured across a full twelve months.
A cancellation for stock you did not have is a defect. A case closed without you resolving it counts against an allowance of two. What Below Standard actually does is the half of this that decides whether your listings are still being shown.
What actually comes back in the box
A used part has no seal, no serial you necessarily recorded, and no packaging that proves it is the same unit. Nothing in any returns policy prevents a different part arriving back than the one that left.
The protection you have is the record you kept before it shipped. Documentation is the countermeasure, not the fine print.
- Photograph casting marks and stamped numbers, not just the part. A casting number in a photo dated before dispatch is evidence; "it looked like that when I packed it" is not.
- Record the condition notes you published, not the ones you remember. The listing as it stood at the moment of sale is the document a dispute turns on.
- Keep the listing after it ends. Most systems delete an ended listing because the part is gone and storage costs money - a reasonable default almost everywhere, and the wrong one here.
What to do this week
- Audit your condition values. Every listing marked new or new other is inside a mandatory returns regime. Decide whether each one should be.
- Check which of your categories are excluded. If your volume is drivetrain, most of it may be outside this entirely.
- Open a live listing and try to change its return policy. Whatever you find is the truth for your account, and it beats anything written about it - including this.
The rule is keyed on a field you filled in yourself. That makes the classification a decision, not a description.